Coming Events

.

Must Reads

  • Ten Universal Principles: A Brief Philosophy of the Life Issues. This book is concerned with: How do we make sense of life? How should we treat others? How should we reasonably be expected to be treated by others? When human life is at stake, are there reasonable principles we can rely on to guide our actions?
  • Same-Sex Marriage: Dangers, Difficulties, Deceptions
  • "Really a Choice?' is a Factazine that explores the effects and consequences of women in society who experience unplanned pregnancy, abortion and associated health issues.
  • You're Teaching My Child What?- A psychiatrist exposes the harm done to children in the name of sex education.
  • Architects of the Culture of Death
  • Economies Rise and Fall with the Family
  • Palliative Care and Compassion. Adding palliative care early to patients’ standard regimens not only improves their quality of life but lengthens their life as well
  • Redeeming a Father's Heart: Men Share Powerful Stories of Abortion Loss and Recovery
  • Mugged by Ultrasound Why so many abortion workers have turned pro-life.
  • Secret Journey
  • Girls and Gardasil: the protection game - A mother and public health student offers ten reasons not to vaccinate children against a sexually transmitted disease
  • Cardinal Rigali: "Contraception and Abortion" Have Created a "Cultural Hostility to Children"
  • The Insanity of Same-Sex Parenting
  • Youtube censors prolife videos
  • On the Demise of Fatherhood
  • Rejecting Men, Embracing Children. Helen Alvaré's article can best be summed up by her quote "We should 'do something' about nonmarital childbearing". Here she brings some insight to a growing problem which is embedded in not only US but also NZ culture
  • Throwing oil on the blaze of teenage sex
  • A Really Long Post About Abortion and Reasoning By Historical Analogy That is Going to Make Virtually All of My Readers Very Angry At Me
  • Love is not enough. Mothers and fathers are not interchangeable. Children need the love of both.
  • 49 Million to 5: In the wake of the shooting of late-term abortionist George Tiller, President Barack Obama sent out a welcome message that this nation would not tolerate attacks on pro-lifers or any other Americans because of their religion or beliefs. Ha ha! Just kidding
  • Secretary of State Clinton Admits Obama will Work to Dismantle Abortion Laws around the World
  • The Problem of Evil
  • Abortion None of Your Business
  • Sweden Rules Gender-Selective Abortions Legal
  • Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide

    Categories

    Right to Life Appeals BSA Decision on Offensive Powershop Poster

    The Chairman,

    Advertising Standards Authority,

    Dear Sir

    Re: Powershop Billboard Advertisement – Complaint 12/688

    Thank you for your letter of 24 January 2013 and your decision on the above complaint.

    I wish to appeal the decision on the following grounds:

    • There is new evidence of sufficient substance to affect the decision.
    • That it is in the interest of natural justice that the matter be reheard.

    The Chairman refers to a previous Complaints Board Decision [10/488]. The Complaints Board was of the opinion that the caricatures were not representative of a group or groups of people.  I respectfully challenge that conclusion. Catholics make up one seventh of the population in New Zealand and are the largest denomination in this country.  To portray the Pope blessing a same sex marriage is ridicule firstly of the person of the Pope and secondly  the teaching authority of the Catholic Church that rests in the Pope and thirdly the belief of Catholics that the institution of marriage is exclusively between one woman and one man.

    Catholics have a great affection for the Pope and closely identify with him. To ridicule the Pope is in effect to ridicule Catholics and their loyalty to the teaching authority of the Catholic Church.    

    The Chairman stated that showing the Pope blessing the marriage was another example of the Advertisers strategy of using irony and humour and in keeping with the advertiser’s campaign slogan of “same power different attitude.” There is a place for humour and satire in advertising there is however no place for ridicule. Bishop Pat Dunne, Catholic Bishop of Auckland, said in an interview with Radio NZ on 12th December that he was outraged by the offensive billboard which was “highly offensive”. He had written to Powershop and requested that the billboards be taken down immediately, they refused. Bishop Dunne was echoing the sentiments of the Catholic community.

    Catholics are very conscious that in the 2000 year history of the Catholic Church there have been periods of intense persecution. Today this is happening  in Egypt, Iran and Iraq. This is marked with Catholics being driven from their homes, arson attacks on Churches and the murder of innocent people. Persecution starts with ridicule  and humiliation and can escalate ultimately to violence against persons and property.

    On the issue of privacy, the chairman noted that the permission of the Pope was not needed as the image is a cartoon used for satire. Is it then permissible for the image of the Pope to be used for ridicule and humiliation without his permission as long as it is a cartoon?

    The Chairman states while acknowledging the offence the advertisement had caused the complainant, the Chairman said the advertisement before her did not reach the threshold to be said to cause serious or widespread offence in light of generally prevailing community standards. 

    I believe that the offending billboard breaches Principle 2 in that it portrays the Pope in a manner which has caused serious widespread contempt and ridicule.

    I believe that this complaint is of great importance, if this complaint is not upheld it will be giving a very strong message to the advertising industry that the ridicule and humiliation of the Pope is acceptable. 

    Yours sincerely

    Ken Orr

     

    For another view on Powershop’s Billboard click here

    1 comment to Right to Life Appeals BSA Decision on Offensive Powershop Poster

    • Rhona

      Given the former Holy Father’s recent resignation, perhaps it might be worth providing a tribute to his various acts of assistance to the pro-life cause?

    Leave a Reply

      

      

      

    You can use these HTML tags

    <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>